By Donald Summers, author of Scaling Altruism
Does your nonprofit have a “strategic plan?” If you aren’t very careful, this document could be an illusion. It talks about what you do, but will it guide your choices and the behavior of your team? And will it show exactly how you plan to sustain and grow your organizational impact to the necessary level – where you are fulfilling your mission instead of nibbling around the edges?
This is because these plans are very hard to do well. If you are a nonprofit, take heart in the fact that people in the private sector struggle with planning as well.
Consider this terrific article from the Harvard Business Review: Your Strategic Plans Probably aren’t Strategic, or Even Plans.
Take a careful look at your document, or one from any socially minded organization. While they are typically filled with evocative terms like “empower” and “equity,” when you examine the architecture and measurements around how the work is actually supposed to happen, there is usually a lack of both specificity and direction.
An effective plan is very specific about what the organization wants to make happen. It is light on adjectives and heavy with measures and numbers: ambitious goals measured in quantitative terms and specific, timed outcomes; clear, concise strategy that describes a coherent, integrated set of choices the organization is going to make; a sustainable, scalable program and business model; milestones and key performance indicators; and, critically, a detailed organizational chart and financial projection. And they also contain all the ways the organization will raise money, earn it, and/or harness investment.
And all this information needs to be crafted into a presentation-ready format of 10 pages or fewer, preferably with an accompanying set of 12 slides that summarize everything.
What an investment-grade business plan contains
A complete plan covers these elements:
- Problem: The problem you are solving (for arts and culture organizations, the joy you add), defined with concise descriptive statistics.
- Solution: What total success looks like in concrete, measurable terms. This is your vision statement.
- Value proposition: Why your organization is the best solution to the problem, with concrete evidence (“proof points”) that your work succeeds.
- Goal: A 5- to 10-year Big, Hairy, Audacious Goal (BHAG) that makes progress toward your ultimate vision.
- Market: How many people or parts of the planet the work will reach, who else is active in the space, and how your effort compares.
- Strategy: The linked set of choices and behaviors that will achieve the BHAG.
- Milestones: Measurable progress points toward the BHAG, often in a “crawl, walk, run” sequence. Each is SMART: Specific, Measurable, Aspirational, Relevant, Timed.
- Metrics: 3 to 5 KPIs for financial, stakeholder, program, and organizational development, divided into lagging indicators (the results you want) and leading indicators (the actions you believe will produce them).
- Marketing: The purpose of marketing in relation to impact and growth, the audience segments and their size, how they will be reached, and how they will be engaged to act.
- Revenue: Strategies for contributed, earned, and loaned revenue from individuals, foundations, corporations, government agencies, and impact capital sources.
- Risk: How the organization will identify and mitigate financial, reputational, legal, governance, operational, and other risks.
- Organization: An org chart showing current staffing and phased expansion.
- Financials: Rolled-up five-year financial projections, with an itemized projection (including salaries) available on request.
- Team: Brief bios of the Board and executive team.
While a challenge to do well, this type of “investment grade” business plan is far superior to the garden-variety nonprofit strategic plan. Yes, it requires that the organization do the hard work to create consensus on direction as well as transparency and accountability of execution. But the benefits are incomparable. Without such a plan that guides the daily behaviors of staff and volunteers, the organization is likely doomed to ineffectiveness. They may have an attractive plan with pretty pictures, but precious little social impact will happen as a result.
Take a look at your organization’s plan
- Does it have a goal expressed as a number? And does this goal make sense compared to the total size of the problem or challenge you are addressing? (Or is it arbitrary?)
- Is this goal backed up with metrics, timelines, and reporting?
- What about scale? Are the goals aiming for growth that is meaningful, compared to the size of the problem you are addressing?
- Is there a detailed, 3-5 year expense projection that calculates how much all this will cost?
- And has the org projected out how all this is going to get paid for?
- Is there a clear, concise, compelling picture of revenue generation from individuals, foundations, corporations, gov’t agencies, and earned income?
- And is all this boiled down to a compelling, concise, comprehensive, 5-10 page document that people can actually read and understand?
While a good nonprofit business plan is very similar in terms of architecture and format to any other type of business plan, there is one very unique feature: at heart, they are public documents. Unlike a proprietary business model that needs to be closely held lest its valuable ideas get stolen, the last 20% or so of a nonprofit business planning process should be completed in partnership with all the nonprofit’s relevant stakeholders, funders and partners.
Not only does this help socialize the organization’s goal, the planners hopefully get supportive feedback and constructive criticism before putting the plan into action.
Follow this guide and you will begin to position your nonprofit as the vehicle for the community– not an inward-facing organization struggling for gifts, but an outward-reaching organization seeking to develop and refine its goals and strategy in consultation with community leaders and experts. Taken as a community-building exercise, then, the challenging process of business plan drafting becomes an exercise in mutual support– exactly how communities are supposed to function.
Not sure where your plan stands? Take the free 10-minute nonprofit assessment.
Related: Nonprofit Strategic Plan Template: Why High-Impact Nonprofits Write a Business Plan Instead
About the author: Donald Summers is the founder of Altruist Partners and author of Scaling Altruism: A Proven Pathway for Accelerating Nonprofit Growth and Impact (Wiley, 2024). His frameworks have helped more than 500 nonprofits in 28 countries raise more than $1 billion.
